An Old House Christmas Carol

By: Conrad Neuf , Contributing Writer
In: Old Houses, Old House Musings, In The News

In the world of historical preservation a developer is often seen as an adversary; the villain with the pencil thin mustache who wants to take the family farm. Old houses cringe and try to blend in when a developer drives down the road and preservationists steel themselves for the long battle they know could be on the horizon. Developers have gained a reputation of only being concerned with lining their pockets and acting with a total disregard for the parts of history that may be lost along the way.

Happy Holidays!--photo from dailygreen.com

Happy Holidays!--photo from dailygreen.com

Preservationists vs. Developers

In my area preservationists fought large court battles that lasted for years in an effort to limit development around the Manassas and Wilderness Civil War Battlefields and similar preservation efforts take place on a smaller scale in towns and counties around the country on a regular basis. I wrote earlier that the downturn in the economy might be causing developers to be a little more cautious and this behavior might be sparing some old houses on desirable properties, but I’m no longer so sure that’s the case.

They might be holding off on their construction plans for the time being, but many are taking advantage of lower land values and homeowner distress to purchase properties at bargain basement prices. Development may be on hold in some areas, but in many cases the demolition of the old houses on the properties has simply been delayed.

Every once in a while a developer comes to their senses much like Ebenezer Scrooge in “A Christmas Carol.” I doubt the executives at Walmart’s corporate headquarters were visited by any ghosts, but they not only spared three historical old houses in Forsyth, Georgia; they contributed $50,000 to renovating them. The three houses range from 96 to 135 years old and are situated in a buffer zone between a new Walmart and the residential neighborhood that adjoins it.

Old House Holiday Cheer!--photo from guy-sports.com

Old House Holiday Cheer!--photo from guy-sports.com

Save Historic Forsyth

The corporation planned to tear the homes down and create a green area in the buffer zone, but a group of Forsyth old house lovers banded together to form Save Historic Forsyth in an effort to save the homes. Unfortunately they were unable to get the backing of Forsyth’s City Council, but they weren’t deterred and one of the preservationists drove to Walmart’s corporate headquarters in Arkansas to confront the company’s executives. She was able to meet with a vice-president in charge of real estate and after visiting Forsyth to view the homes, he agreed they deserved to be saved.

It’s a great story and shows what can happen when preservationists band together; no corporation is too large to take on and not all developers are just about the money. I doubt this generous gesture is going to break Walmart and a little bit of good publicity around the holidays never hurts.


Post a Comment

Enter the text shown above

  1. 3 Responses  to “An Old House Christmas Carol”

  2. Aug 29, 2011
    Megan and Frank I couldn't agree more! While the acts of some may give the entire profession a bad name, there are some developers out there that have a concern for saving history and don't mind spending a few extra dollars to incorporate an old house or building into their plans rather than take the easy and less expensive approach of just bulldozing them down. It may even make financial sense as it definitely creates some good publicity for the development.
  3. Aug 29, 2011
    I hope that more developers see the potential benefits in rehabbing historic properties--financially, culturally, and for a better quality of life. We as preservationists need to show our support to those developers that do make the right choice to preserve rather than destroy.
  4. frank
    Aug 29, 2011
    There are some developers who do it right. In my town, Macey's shut it doors last year, but a developer is taking the old historic brick building and rehabbing it into apartments and ground level retail. While they could have just bulldozed it, they chose to the right thing!