The American Foursquare

By: Bill Kibbel , Contributing Writer
In: Old Houses, House Styles

We looked at a home this weekend and were wondering what style it is.  The agent called it a two-story Colonial, but it’s listed as less than 100 years old.  It has a rear one-story addition, but the original house looks like a big square box with a pyramid for a roof.  The front porch looks original.  It’s very large with square columns supporting the porch roof.  If you have any info on this type of house, we would appreciate it.

I’m frequently presented with opportunities to tease some real estate sales folks about their knowledge of architectural terms and styles. Any home that is two stories and is somewhat lacking in decorative elements is usually listed as a Colonial. The home you describe has some splendid details that are consistent with a unique type of family home that was most popular during the first third of the 20th century.

The American Foursquare

The American Foursquare

The American Foursquare appears throughout the U.S. in mostly urban neighborhoods.  That’s not to say that you won’t find them in rural areas–some are even farmhouses. A large majority were built between 1895 and the late 1930s. I call it a type of house rather than a particular style.  The basic form of the structure of the house classifies it as an American Foursquare. The style used on the other details can vary greatly.

The Form
The homes are usually two-stories. There is a large attic that when finished, the home could be considered a 2½ story. They were commonly built with the top few feet of the basement walls extending up out of the ground, creating a tall, boxy home on the lot. A steep-sloped hipped roof creates the large attic. The roof has a very short ridge, while others have no ridge, resulting in a pyramidal roof. There is almost always a dormer window, centered on the front slope.

The early models might have a box bay or angle bay extension on one side. Occasionally a bay pops out of the front of the second floor. I don’t think I’ve never seen a Foursquare without a covered front porch.

One other thing–they’re square.

The Layout
The most common floor plan consists dividing each level into four primary spaces. The first floor usually contains an entry foyer, often with the stairs to the second floor, a living room, dining room, and kitchen. The second floor in the larger models has four bedrooms and a bath.  Some smaller sized homes have 3 bedrooms and a bath.

I find very few that have had major structural changes from the original floor plan, proving the original design to still be functional for today’s modest families. The most common changes are a rear one story addition–to accommodate a larger eat-in kitchen–and finishing the attic into an office, studio, or bedroom.

The Details
The Foursquare has been built with every building material available at that time. Masonry–brick, stone, concrete block, and structural terra cotta, was easily used to create the square-box exterior walls. Wood frame was also used for many and exterior wall covering choices at the time were plentiful. Unfortunately, most wood constructed models are now encapsulated with modern vinyl or aluminum siding.

Some early homes had a few decorative details left over from the Victorian period, but much less extravagant. Some followed the Colonial Revival style and included a symmetrical facade.  Many style details were saved only for the prominent front porch. Later Foursquare styles were influenced by the details of the Prairie, Craftsman, Mission, Arts and Crafts styles and interiors began looking similar to bungalows.

Still Strong

The American Foursquare was considered a practical, economic type of house. Its simple form was easily constructed, is easily maintained and the interiors maximized usable spaces. I think the observation that so few have been significantly altered shows that this type of structure may be one of the most sensible and livable since the early “Colonial” homes.


Post a Comment

Enter the text shown above

  1. 14 Responses  to “The American Foursquare”

  2. David Benavente Jr
    Nov 12, 2014
    Our home in emerson, ia was built back in the 1800's old farm house. The woodwork would be impossible to receate...it has a back addition with a shed type roof...want to do remodle on house. Without losing the old historic four square original...???? Need ideas??
  3. mary lesperance
    Oct 3, 2013
    are craftsmen homes still being built? are there any for sale anywhere in florida? mary
  4. Erik
    Jan 20, 2013
    I live in an owner-built 1909 four square in St. Paul, MN. It has an unfinished space in the second floor hallway under the attic stairs. I've seen built in closet/cupboards in this space in other four squares and would like to build one into mine. Could anybody point me to or send me photos of your second floor hallway built-ins so I can try to match the style and design? Thanks!
  5. Aug 29, 2011
    Beautiful house! My uncle live in an American four square for a few years in college and i always loved playing on the hardwood flooring in his kitchen!
  6. Aug 29, 2011
    I've participated in the restoration of several these homes, but never had the luxury of living in one. One the whole, the American Foursquare is one of my all-time favorites for being accommodating, efficient and truly homey.
  7. John
    Aug 29, 2011
    I have a foursquare type house but my attic is very sloped and has only 2 roofed sides. The front and back of the house are tall and triangular. But it shares most of the floor plan of a foursquare. There are alot of houses in buffalo ny that have my style but i still dont know what it is. If you can help i would be greatfull. John
  8. emily
    Aug 29, 2011
    my 1910 foursquare house has no porch and there are many in my town (Rochester MN approx. 100,000 pop.) that have no porch. a neighbor, who is currently adding a porch, said that many porches have simply rotted off over the years, or sagged so much that people took them off. we call our house "faceless" because it is so flat. i suspect that is the case for my house, because the siding and foundation condition is different where the porch "should" be. you can still recognize the foursquare house easily by the shape of the structure and exterior window placement. maybe this has been mentioned here, but also as information readily available on the web, the foursquare was a popular catalog house.
  9. Aug 29, 2011
    I agree of it being economic. What would be best is to have hardwood floors that would really bring out the authenticity and uniqueness of this type of house.
  10. j delgado
    Aug 29, 2011
    we bought our two story house in Arkansas in 2002. i thought it was of some what victorian style. now i have found out it is american foursquare, with a little victorian style wood trim. two story,attic,basement,three bedroom,full bath,half bath,open front porch,two balcony style porch on back. it had old carriage/garage beside it. small little drive. it also had the old wood windows with rope/weights. it was remodeled some what a few years earlier. they put new kitchen cabinets,glass front,glass shelves,pink stone tile on floor/counter tops,new electrical,bath tub with jets,also shower over tub,white tile on bath room floor ,green tile in shower,it has the old wood doors with skeleton key,old wood front door with glass, i think it is original door. we have been working on this house a little at a time. we changed the windows, to storm windows for heat and cold purposes. we had the carriage house/garage taken down. we put in a almost six car drive. we replaced a picture window in dining room, with a larger window with thirty two small panes trimmed in white. this helps with the hot sun coming in. we have painted inside and out. we also replaced the heating/air units, up and down stairs. we had insulation put in attic and walls and under living room floor. we also have the original white fireplace. our electric/gas bill runs $700 dollars in the winter. we went total elect. now our bill is under $125.00 dollars. we also changed out our old hot water heater, with a small box that heats only the water you need. plus it is on the wall and is only one foot by one foot. my husband just got the new elect bill, $123 dollars. we are still working on the house. our house looks alot like the picture above, but ours is taller and slimmer but some what the same style. our deed says it was built in 1920.
  11. Barbara W Morrison
    Aug 29, 2011
    Hi, I grew up in and live in an American Foursquare that my grandfather built, my Dad was born in and I was raised in. It was built in 1923 and still has it's original character such as it's tin shingle roof, a terne front and back porch roof, rope windows with weights, 5 or 6 panel horizontal panel doors with original locks, same front door with skeleton key, 2 chimneys, horizontal beadboard on the walls and ceilings and electrical in the attic on porcelain knobs and hardwood floors. My house has the entrance to the side and the stairs are immediately to the right which are part of the downstairs and upstairs hall which is considered a room. We have 3 bedrooms upstairs of which you can only access the corner bedroom from either of the two bedrooms exiting into the upstairs hall. Downstairs, we have a kitchen, living room and dining room. I have research much over the past 15 years because of trying to maintain the integrity of my home. I am finally at a point of updating as to blow insulation into the walls of which are balloon framed, add some type of heating and air. I am very much open to ideas as to keep my original windows or update to wood replacement windows. Electrical has been an issue since I do not want to tear out any of my beadboard so I have considered option of placing it behind or within my baseboard. Our ceilings are 9 foot downstairs and 8 foot upstairs. Our windows are 2 over 2 and is considered to be farmhouse windows. We have a freeze plate above the second floor and no dormer. All of our doors and windows are 32 inches wide and 66 inches tall. All of the supplies and materials were purchased through a hardware store in a small town I grew up visiting when I was a young girl.